Georgia football: Kirby Smart's quick thinking puts him among nation's elite in-game strategists
I want you to remember 3 moments with me from Georgia’s improbable comeback victory over Ohio State on Saturday in the Peach Bowl. I understand that may be a sizable request — excitement from the game, celebrations of the new year and a seemingly endless flow of drinks have probably damaged your recollection.
But it’s important to remember these moments, because they may well have been the ones that saved Georgia’s hopes of repeating as national champions. Here they are:
- A decision in the closing moments of the 1st half to exercise patience and sit on the football going into the locker room rather than making an attempt at points to steal back some of the momentum Georgia had lost on an Ohio State touchdown moments before.
- A decision to go for a field goal late, trailing by 14 points and nearing a point when the clock was as much an opponent as the ones in scarlet and grey on the other sideline.
- A split-second choice to call a timeout fractions of a second before the Buckeyes snapped the ball on a fake punt that would have netted them a back-breaking 1st down.
What do all of these moments have in common?
In a game where it’s normally just wrong coaching decisions being questioned for the outcome, these were moves that Georgia coach Kirby Smart made that had tangible positive impact on the Bulldogs’ chances.
I don’t consider it hyperbole to say that they are the reason Georgia is still alive. It’s a far cry from the coach many criticized early in his tenure. Praised for his recruiting and program-building prowess, Smart was still held back by his game management.
But on Saturday — if it weren’t clear already — Smart emphasized at every possible opportunity why he has grown into America’s very best football coach not named Nick Saban.
Let’s take a closer look at those moments:
Taking it easy before the half
The Bulldogs had seized the momentum.
After falling behind 21-7 early, Georgia had come roaring back before the half to score 17 straight and take a 24-21 lead inside of 2 minutes. It began to feel like the Bulldogs had reached that point where they would overcome the slow start, get some stops and begin to put Ohio State away for a clean Playoff semifinal victory.
Only that wasn’t going to happen. Not on Buckeyes quarterback CJ Stroud’s watch. Stroud took just 4 plays to put his team back in the end zone and wrest back all that momentum Georgia had established.
Georgia had 49 seconds and timeouts left to play with, though, and the conventional wisdom among the Bulldog faithful that surrounded me that night was that the team needed points before the break.
Georgia called a couple of pass plays. Both were broken up, and 1 was tossed into dangerous territory by quarterback Stetson Bennett IV. Smart had seen enough — he called for a kneel to run out the clock, ran onto the field, put his arm around Bennett and began to coach his signal-caller on the way to the locker room.
Simple. A small moment. One you could easily forget in the broad scheme of a game like Saturday’s. But significant. Oh, so significant.
It showed restraint. It showed confidence in his players. Smart had seen the holes his running backs were running through. He had seen the opportunities his offense would have. Rather than risking a turnover that could have given everything back to Ohio State, he instead chose patience.
This is a man who once ran a fake punt with a backup quarterback who had never been in that formation all season right into the teeth of an opposing defense.
That was desperation, a trait Smart has grown far beyond.
Settling for 3 down 14 in the 4th quarter
Georgia had already missed 2 field goals, a rare occurrence for a kicker in Jack Podlesny who has been the definition of automatic throughout his career. The Bulldogs had held Ohio State to 3 on its previous drive, and the clock was nearing 10 minutes left in the game.
It felt like a touchdown was needed to begin cutting possessions off the Buckeyes’ lead. Again, Smart chose patience. He knew that more than anything, the Bulldogs needed points.
So when they faced 4th-and-goal from the Ohio State 13-yard line, they elected to take the 3 points rather than chase a low-percentage play, making the score 38-27. It was still a multi-possession game, but the intangible factor of momentum remained neutral rather than flipping heavily in favor of Ohio State.
Again, a simple moment. Easily forgettable. But significant.
The greatest timeout ever called
Once again — not hyperbole.
I’ve seen the pictures that showed Ohio State had 12 men on the field for its crucial fake punt try, but no flag appeared on the attempt, and it’s possible it never would have.
Smart never gave it a chance.
When Ohio State lined up with 8:58 to go in the game, still ahead 38-27 but facing a 4th down in its own territory, it was in an alignment Smart had seen on film. The coach said Georgia has had 2 punts faked against it this year, and it is aware of when opponents might try to steal possessions.
Smart saw the formation, and knowing how valuable timeouts were going to be down the stretch, he made a snap decision to stop the play before it started. The play was run on the field. The Buckeyes converted the 1st down. No flag was thrown.
Officials huddled and determined the timeout had come before the snap, and the play was erased.
It saved the game for the Bulldogs, and it may well have won them a 2nd consecutive national title.
In a different lifetime — back when Georgia was still chasing its demons, namely Saban and Alabama — questionable coaching decisions were the norm. Fake punt attempts, poor clock management, a quarterback room as fluid as any in the country.
Now, more than just an elite recruiter and motivator, Smart may be making his case as one of the best in-game strategists we’ve seen.
Kirby made a Smart decision. Heeeeee haaaaaw, get it?
In all seriousness, he’s a fantastic coach. Wish AU would have hired him when they had the chance, but no, AU had to AU.
To be fair: At least you guys aren’t Florida. I mean AU is still a respectable and desirable job.
We just happened to hit the jackpot at the right time with our coaching hire. And it’s not like firing a really good winning coach to woo a defensive savant 1st time HC didn’t come with huge risk. That’s why I like you guys hiring Freeze so much: the dude is a offensive savant and the hire is high-risk high-reward. Hiring Harsin was moderate-risk low-reward. Whereas UF literally hired the only guy with a winning record that wanted the job, and AU actually had many suitors.
“We just happened to hit the jackpot at the right time with our coaching hire.”
Coach MR was getting older (health issues). UGA made the right hire.
Well there was that but I think they were convinced to pull the trigger on Kirby when Sakerlina decided they wanted him now. The UGA faithful took a swing at what they believed was the only chance they’d get with CKS
The restraint lesson stemmed, in my eyes, from earlier this year, when right before the half against Miss St, Stetson forced a ball and it went for a pick 6 (RIP Coach Leach).
And the fake punt TO is legendary. I know OSU had 12 men on the field, but rather than leave it in the officials hands (Tyler Simmons was onsides, false start 2nd and 26 or whatever lame excuse I’ve heard) Kirby pulled out the greatest TO ever called.
Tyler Simmons was onsides. That’s an indisputable fact at this point.
Yes, but irrelevant as Bama’s RB was illegally in motion. At most a 5 yard penalty and rekick.
you mean there were two incorrect/missed calls to bama’s favor on that play? of all the scenarios there, uga got the worst, while bama got the best.
bad and/or missed calls happen all the time, but the above play and sequence of events certainly stands out.
Simply saying that in a perfect world the offsides call isn’t why we didn’t the Title in 2017.
In an imperfect world, maybe they do. We’ll never know. But I ain’t living in 2017. The present is much more rewarding.
Not only was there the risk of Stetson throwing an interception, but Kirby didn’t want to give Ohio State the ball back with 30 seconds. They had just shown they could move the ball down the field and probably gotten at least a field goal.
Most of those negative narratives concerning Coach Smart were contained to this site. His capabilities have long been acknowledged on National publications.
Agreed. Remember when the Bama fans called him Kirby “Dumb”? They said it was Saban’s defense and recruiting at Bama that was the main reason for Bama’s success. Kirby was just riding Saban’s coat tails and he would be terrible at UGA.
Another great Bama take.
Gator fans were more vocal than Bama fans IMO. Mullins is better, Coach O is better, Coach Malzahn is better. Good times.
Kirby has certainly come a long way. From being mocked for some of his early decisions to being revered for his recent ones. That’s growth. His only prior “weakness” is now a strength.
Agree Marine. Smart has improved in his overall coaching, adjustments and decision making skills. The comparisons to the GOAT are still not warranted but he is headed in that direction.
Hopefully he’s learned from the Peach Bowl mistakes and will have a better plan for TCU. I’m too old to sit there and take that for 60min in the upper deck.
The defense executed the game plan to a T. The problem was Stroud has wheels and we didn’t know. We definitely know Duggan has wheels.
For me, Kirby came of age in 2020. He fired James Coley and hired Todd Monken thus bringing the UGA offense into the 21st century.
And where did Coley go to ruin more offense?… The ATM to pull out cash and sit in his ash
I’m sure Kirby would just soon not have a shootout if given the choice, but he has built a team that can do it if necessary.
Monken was an excellent hire. Hope he stays a long time.
I hope Bobo is sponging in everything he can from Todd, no way Monken isn’t lured away soon
King Kirby.
Definitely cool to have flipped in-game coaching experience from a liability to a strength. And not be left to complain about a missed call after a loss!
Greatest timeout ever called? I highly doubt it. They had 12 men on the field. That automatically meant something was up if the GA assistants can count.
Time-out to ice Ruggles wasn’t chopped liver
Maybe jersey doesn’t watch football too much….I wouldn’t either if I were a gator fan. The 12 men flag was not thrown (though it should’ve been) and wouldn’t be a reviewable call. So, NO that call wouldn’t have made a difference because it was missed by the horrible PAC12 crew.
Great game, great judgement calls. My controversial opinion is this: Saban and Alabama tend to tighten up in big games when things are not going well. He gets real conservative and he doesn’t fully trust his athletes.
In the past Kirby would do the same. In the Peach Bowl, I think he was more patient than pulling back conservative and he’s finally trusting Monken to take the reigns.
Elite recruiter? Yes.
Elite strategist? No. What a homer article.
Must be a Gump or a ‘turd or a Hillbilly.
Either way, your bitter, salty tears are DELICIOUS!
I think the TO before last-second field goal attempt can be included here.
Last year, if memory serves, Saban did not try to ice A&M’s kicker with TO’s to spare and lost by three early in that season.
Leaving it all on the field includes TO’s, imo
Test